Why Choosing a Childfree Life is Just as Valid as Motherhood
When a woman says she wants kids, she is celebrated. Baby showers, glowing compliments, Instagram and Facebook likes galore. She’s celebrated as a perfect, selfless, nurturing woman who is fulfilling her “true purpose.”
But when a woman says she doesn’t want kids? Suddenly, the celebration stops and the interrogation begins. She’s so selfish. Cold. Immature. Broken. Questioned over and over again until she either defends herself or stays silent.
Here’s the thing: I’m not anti-motherhood, anti-child, or anti-natalist. I don’t think parents are “bad” and childfree people are “good.” I’m a feminist. I’m pro-choice. I’m pro-autonomy. I’m pro-validation. And I’m sick of living in a world where one life path is glorified and the other is demonized.
The Double Standard: Why Moms Get Applause and Childfree Women Get Interrogated
Motherhood is often painted as the “natural” path for women. It’s celebrated, praised, even expected. Open any social media app and you’ll be bombarded with baby content: gender reveals, sonograms, pumpkin patch family photos, glowing mom-to-be posts, endless registries. Motherhood is packaged as this joyful, supportive sisterhood of “mamas stick together.” Yet ask any woman and she’ll tell you—the most toxic Facebook group in town is the local moms’ group. And when new mothers inevitably struggle after the baby arrives, they’re met with a flood of hollow comments like “prayers mama” or “you’re doing great mama,” while the actual support is nowhere to be found.
Meanwhile, when a woman chooses to be childfree? Suddenly she’s selfish, cold, or “missing something.” We’re harassed by “mommy-jackers” who turn every conversation back to their kids, or by random men online insisting we’re ugly, lonely, and doing the world a favor by not reproducing. We’re treated like witches in the woods plotting the downfall of children everywhere, when really all we want is a little peace and quiet in our own lives and homes.
Funny how one choice is framed as nurturing while the other is treated like a personal failing. The truth is, society loves to police women’s decisions no matter what we do. Have kids? You’re judged for not doing it “right.” Don’t have kids? You’re judged for opting out altogether. It’s not about motherhood versus childfreedom. It’s about patriarchy’s obsession with controlling women’s lives and bodies. Both paths deserve respect.
Your life. Your choice. Your story. Subscribe to Her Childfree Life and never miss an essay.
The Myth of Womanhood = Motherhood (And Why Patriarchy Loves It)
One of the favorite recurring themes I see (especially from men in my Threads) is this idea that my “biological purpose” is to reproduce. These dudes clearly failed most of their GED but clung to the one fact they remembered: people with uteruses can have babies. Congrats on your one gold star in anatomy, champ. The patriarchy took that little factoid and ran with it, turning it into a weapon to keep women in their place.
Because here’s the truth: we are far less “productive” for capitalism when we’re raising kids. It’s harder for us to chase our own ambitions when every hour is consumed by childcare. And let’s be real, in a lot of cases also by caring for them as man-children. God forbid we ask them to contribute after their “long day” at the office, away from the noise and chaos, needing nothing more than their throne, their remote, and their self-importance over their five-figure salary.
As Sheila Heti so brilliantly put it:
“There is something threatening about a woman who is not occupied with children. There is something at-loose-ends feeling about such a woman. What is she going to do instead? What sort of trouble will she make?”
Exactly. A woman without kids isn’t “empty.” She’s dangerous to the status quo.
A Full Life Without Kids: Why Mine Isn’t Empty
Your life is not less fulfilling if you don’t have children. It simply looks different from the script we’re fed in every movie and TV show. Society tells us life hasn’t “really started” until you’ve had kids. But for me, the idea of having a child feels like the end of my life as I know it. Everything I’ve built, everything I cherish, would change forever. You can’t “return a child to sender.” There are no do-overs, and I’m deeply content with the way my life is now.
I feel full. My time is my own. If I found myself pregnant with no choice but to give birth, I know it would push me to the edge of my mental health. I’d need serious support just to survive it. Instead, I get to live a life I choose. After work I can go to the gym. I can spend time with my dogs. I have a puppy I’m training and loving through all his goofy little stages. And then I can leave him safely at home while I go do other things (you can’t crate children, after all).
I can plan vacations whenever I want. I can move anywhere without worrying about school districts. I’m not chained to summer breaks or constantly changing schedules. I don’t have to budget for childcare or kids’ clothes. I only have to take care of me, and that’s enough. My life isn’t empty. It’s mine—and that’s exactly how I want it.
Stop Calling Motherhood the “Higher” Path
Motherhood gets painted as the ultimate sacrifice. It is the noblest, most selfless thing a woman can do. Meanwhile, being childfree? That’s branded as selfish. Because apparently choosing a life you actually want, on your own terms, is more selfish than bringing a whole new human into the world just because society told you to. Make it make sense.
Here’s the truth: it’s selfish to pressure women into roles they don’t want. It’s selfish to demand someone give up her time, body, and future just to tick a box labeled “acceptable womanhood.” What could possibly be more self-absorbed than believing every uterus exists to serve someone else’s idea of purpose?
Real empowerment isn’t about sacrifice. It’s about choice. It’s about women defining their own purpose, whether that’s raising kids, raising dogs, raising hell, or raising their own damn standards.
Autonomy is the Point. Always.
The real issue isn’t whether motherhood is good or bad. It’s whether women get to choose without being judged. Some women thrive as mothers. Some thrive childfree. Both are valid, because both are chosen. What’s not valid is a culture that shames, pressures, or guilt-trips women into one path while pretending the other doesn’t exist.
Queer communities have always understood this. They’ve modeled for decades what it looks like to build chosen families, to love outside rigid boxes, to create lives that don’t orbit around the idea of the perfect family. That’s proof that there are endless ways to build meaning and connection. Motherhood is one way—but it’s not the only way.
At the end of the day, autonomy is what matters. Not a gold star for sacrifice, not a “good mom” badge, not a perfect family photo. Just the right to live your damn life without everyone else putting you on trial for it.
Her Childfree Life exists because of readers who support the work through The Full Blog — where I share early releases, longer essays, and members-only reflections.
Unlock full access to Her Childfree Life’s complete collection of essays, reflections, and commentary. Optional access to the paid version of Her Childfree Life's Substack, if you prefer to get posts directly in your inbox or join community discussions there.